Автор: Лопатинский Илья Владимирович

Статья из тематических разделов:

Author: Ilya V. Lopatinsky
REGARDING THE PROBLEM OF INADMISSIBILITY OF CRITERIA FOR RE-EVALUATING EVIDENCE BY ARBITRATION COURTS OF CASSATION

ABSTRACT
The article addresses the issue of "inadmissibility of re-evaluation" of judicial acts of lower courts by higher courts. This category well-established in practice arises due to the lack of normative provisions or a consistent explanation from the higher courts in the Russian Federation governing the use of the term "re-evaluation of evidence," which creates a significant gap in the legal system. Particular attention is paid to legal precedents, which vividly illustrate the problem under consideration. Based on the results, the author proposes measures that, if implemented, could theoretically improve the quality of judicial acts and boost the effectiveness of the judicial system as a whole.

Ключевые слова: переоценка доказательств, оценка доказательств, критерии оценки доказательств, арбитражные суды кассационной инстанции, достоверность доказательств.
Keywords: re-evaluation of evidence, evaluation of evidence, criteria for evaluating evidence, arbitration courts of cassation, reliability of evidence.